A common occurrence that begets enough angst for several stagings of “Hamlet” is an actor’s pivotal decision to go for the big bucks or to pursue theater as art. “I Hate Hamlet” by Paul Rudnick, which is currently onstage via Southbank Theatre Company, is a farcical look at this conundrum through the character of Andrew Rally (J. Charles Weimer), a Hollywood TV actor whose primetime series has been canceled.
To his horror, his manager, Lillian (Wendy Brown), casts him in the New York Central Park production of “Hamlet.” Andrew has zero confidence that his small screen skills can transfer into live theater, let alone Shakespeare. Come to find out, his realtor, uber-Jersey-twanged Felicia (Jean Arnold), has set him up in an apartment that once belonged to the Shakespearian legend John Barrymore (Kevin Caraher), whose ghost is summoned by Andrew’s Shakespeare crisis. Barrymore (d. 1942) was a real star of both stage and screen and is especially remembered for his performances as Richard III and Hamlet.
On the surface, “I Hate Hamlet” is a lighthearted, comedic exploration of ego, legacy, and art. It’s a love letter to thespians, a rare insight for the audience, and accessible to both. The play takes some swings at vainglory, but it does so with genuine affection for both the artists and the art form.
It’s possible to deep dive into “I Hate Hamlet,” examining its themes, etc. But right now, focusing on the funny is one way to bolster mental health, and after the election train wreck, I think everyone needs a few good laughs.