Review: Fort Worth Symphony delivers extravagant Zemlinsky, ragged Brahms


FORT WORTH — Chances to hear Alexander Zemlinsky’s The Mermaid don’t come along every day. But there it was, all three movements and 45 minutes of it, on Friday night’s Fort Worth Symphony Orchestra concert at Bass Performance Hall. Led by principal guest conductor Kevin John Edusei, the program also included Brahms’ Second Piano Concerto, with pianist Andreas Haefliger. It was not, alas, one of the orchestra’s better nights.

The early 1870s were a fertile time for composers’ births: Viennese-born Zemlinsky was part of a baby boom including Scriabin, Vaughan Williams, Rachmaninoff, Reger and Schoenberg. Although only three years younger, Schoenberg became a Zemlinsky student.

Composed in 1902-3, The Mermaid was a response to romantic disappointment, after Zemlinsky’s student Alma Schindler spurned his affections to marry Gustav Mahler. It was also inspired by Hans Christian Andersen’s fairy tale The Little Mermaid, about disappointment and sacrifice. Zemlinsky apparently identified himself with the spurned mermaid, Schindler with the prince who marries another.

Advertisement

The music sometimes evokes scenes from the fairy tale, including rippling waters, a great storm and a ball. The mermaid is personified by solo violin.

News Roundups

Catch up on the day’s news you need to know.

Zemlinsky indulges luxurious orchestral resources, including six horns. The music rises and falls, ebbs and surges, in often complex textures. The musical language is late romantic, richly colored, lush with chromaticism.

Leading with gestures generously expressive but precise, Edusei seemed in full command of the sprawling work. But he gave no less attention to details of color and texture. The orchestra gave him its considerable all. Violin solos could have used more precise tuning here and there, but there were other notable solos for cello, horn and clarinet.

Advertisement

It was all rather much of a muchness, but the audience responded with enthusiasm. A multiplicity of microphones indicated a recording in the works. Personally, I don’t need to hear the piece again.

The Brahms has had bad luck lately. A month after an unsubtle Dallas Symphony performance, with a sometimes shaky Rudolf Buchbinder, Haefliger sometimes seemed to struggle with an admittedly formidable work.

The orchestra sometimes got louder than necessary, but for the most part Edusei evinced careful attention to dynamics and clarity. The opening horn solo, warmly intoned by Gerald Wood, was about halfway between the “traditional” slow tempo and the pace marked in the score. While most performances belabor the cello solo opening the slow movement, Allan Steele must have been quite close to Brahms’ mobile marking — although a less rapid vibrato would have been preferable.

Advertisement

As with Buchbinder in Dallas, Haefliger played most of the notes, but there were too many treble splats and too many murky clatters blurring what Brahms wrote. Lacking a warm center, Haefliger’s tone turned hard under pressure. When the going got tough, he sometimes rushed, challenging Edusei to keep up.

Details

Repeats at 7:30 p.m. Saturday and 2 p.m. Sunday at Bass Performance Hall, Fourth and Commerce, Fort Worth. $26 to $99. 817-665-6000, fwsymphony.org.

Related Stories
Review: Another splendid Dallas Symphony concert: Tchaikovsky, Britten, Akutagawa

On Thursday night, a fresh program from the Dallas Symphony Orchestra was played with passion and elegance under guest conductor Yutaka Sado. The Tchaikovsky Pathétique Symphony was gripping start to finish, and Sado and pianist Alessandro Taverna made a brilliant case for Benjamin Britten’s Piano Concerto.
Cliburn 2022 silver medalist Anna Geniushene has a new CD of lullabies

Of the six Van Cliburn International Piano Competitions I’ve covered, in whole or in part, the 2022 contest was particularly remarkable in one respect: All three of the medalists were genuinely distinctive and expressive musicians — as well as, of course, accomplished technicians.
Review: Dallas Symphony supplies brilliant Strauss, challenging new Ukrainian works

One could hardly overlook the tragic political undertow of the Dallas Symphony Orchestra’s Saturday night program. Led by a Ukrainian guest conductor, Kirill Karabits, it included new war-born works by two Ukrainian composers, and, in Inbal Segev, an Israeli-born cellist.
Review: Conductor Anna Skryleva got brilliant playing from Fort Worth Symphony

We’re blessed with two excellent professional orchestras around here, playing in two very fine halls. After the Dallas Symphony Orchestra’s splendid Saturday night concert at the Meyerson Symphony Center, the Fort Worth Symphony did itself proud Sunday afternoon at Bass Performance Hall.
Review: Dallas Symphony delivers glorious Brahms, Sibelius

Review: The Dallas Symphony concert Nov. 4, under British guest conductor Mark Wigglesworth, was one of the orchestra’s most satisfying — and, when appropriate, thrilling — in recent memory.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *