Jeopardy! viewers sympathized with contestant Scott Plummer on Thursday’s (November 16) episode after an “unfair” wordplay clue tripped him up and caused him to lose the game.

Plummer, a one-day champion from Season 38, faced off against two-day Season 37 champ Tim Moon and two-day Season 38 champ Amy Bekkerman in the latest episode of Champions Wildcard, which sees brief champions from Seasons 37 & 38 competing to earn a spot in the upcoming Tournament of Champions.