Uh-oh, Special Agent Jessica Knight (Katrina Law) isn’t going to like this! Sure, she and Dr. Jimmy Palmer (Brian Dietzen) may have broken up and want what’s best for each other, but we still have hope they’ll find their way back together. But NCIS is adding a new wrinkle to that.

TV Insider has learned exclusively that Erinn Hayes guest stars in the March 3 episode, “Close to Home.” She plays Wendy Hill, a fellow neighbor of Jimmy’s that he meets at their H.O.A. cocktail hour event. Check out the full version of our first look at her and Jimmy getting close and having a drink together below.