If you didn’t know, Selena and Benny went public with their relationship last December and have repeatedly gushed about each other over the months.

Selena has made it clear that she and Benny are super happy, telling Vanity Fair just last month:  “I’ve never been loved this way. He’s just been a light. A complete light in my life. He’s my best friend. I love telling him everything.”

With this in mind, several internet users questioned the status of Selena and Benny’s relationship after seeing the video of her dancing closely with Edgar. Not only did some fans speculate that Selena had cheated on Benny, but others theorized that she and Edgar were actually dating.

The backlash even wound up sparking think-pieces; this article from Vulture defended Selena, arguing that she and Edgar are just “clearly just girls having fun.”